Best Cookie Jars

Who doesn’t love cookies? Everyone knows that cookie jars are at the center of any warm and friendly kitchen. They make great wedding and housewarming gifts. But with so many different options available on the market, it can be difficult to decide on the best. Let us help. In this article, we’ll offer up four of our favorite cookie jar options for your convenience. With a wide variety of styles, handy features, and jar shapes, you’re bound to find the perfect cookie jar for you and yours.

Get access to everything we publish when you sign up for Outside+.

Most Kid-Friendly

Pusheen Sculpted Cookie Jar


Adorable Cookie Kitty. This cookie jar is bound to give you a smile every time you see it on the counter. Your children will love grabbing a treat from this cool cat!

What We Liked

This adorable Pusheen-themed cookie jar will stand out in your kitchen, and it makes a great “prize jar” for your kiddos after they’ve completed their chores. The sculpted, ceramic stoneware is dishwasher safe, making the vessel super easy to clean. You’ll love seeing this smiling kitty design on a regular basis. Plus, the jar is packaged in a decorative gift box, making this an excellent present for the cat-lover in your life. Buy Here.

Most Classic

Anchor Hocking 1.5-Gallon Montana Glass Jar 


Sturdy Cookie Jar. This classic glass jar effectively keeps your cookies fresh while putting them on display. It’s both old fashioned and modern.

What We Liked

We love the classic look of this glass jar which keeps your cookies on display while also keeping them fresh and crisp. Notably, this cookie jar is made of USA-crafted glass, which speaks to its top-quality construction. With its neutral, sleek metal lid, this cookie jar will look great in any style environment. The jar also comes in a smaller size for other baking or pantry items. Order Online.

Editor’s Choice

Airtight POP Medium Cookie Jar


Airtight Glass Jar. Oxo offers this excellent airtight cookie jar to keep your favorite baked goods ultra-fresh. Your cookies will definitely be on display in these spotless glass containers.

What We Liked

If you’re looking for a simple, effective solution to keep your cookies fresh, this is the perfect choice. Oxo jars are fashioned with a vacuum-sealed top to ensure that all excess air is effectively kept out of the jar. The jars come in small, medium, and large sizes to fit any counter. Plus, the jars are fashioned with BPA-free plastic which speaks to their high-quality construction and value. We also appreciated the flat back design, which allowed us to push the jars against the backsplash and save room on countertops. Get Yours Today.

Runner Up

Old Dutch Stainless Steel Hammered Cookie Jar


Sturdy Hammered Jar. This cookie jar has an aesthetically pleasing rustic appearance combined with a sturdy stainless steel construction. 

What We Liked

You’ll love the look and feel of this durable stainless steel cookie jar. The jar has an extensive 4-quart capacity and fresh seal features to keep your cookies crisp. You’re also able to order other kitchen containers with a similar aesthetic so that you can keep everything stylishly coordinated. Overall, this jar is simply stunning with its high-polish finish and simple, no-fuss functionality. Purchase Here.