Best Pie Dishes for Homemade Desserts
It's so great to have a well-made pie dish for both its function and appeal. You’ll feel like a proper baker when you transport your pies from oven to table, and from home to event or party. With pie dishes, you want one that is built to last, of course. If you happen to drop it or jostle it, it should be tough enough to withstand an impact. It’s up to your personal preference whether you want ceramic, glass, or some other material. Also, consider dish depth and even versatility, as some dishes could be used for other recipes besides desserts. As you browse our favorite pie dishes out there, consider what is most important to you. Is it the depth? Color scheme? Material? Maybe you want one with deeply-fluted edges for a signature crust. Think about what you need as a baker yourself, and make your purchase based on those particulars.
Heading out the door? Read this article on the new Outside+ app available now on iOS devices for members! Download the app.
Most Versatile
Rose Levy Beranbaum’s Perfect Pie Plate
Pie Dish for Many Recipes. This heavy-duty pie dish is suitable for a lot more than just pies, as you can add many other concoctions to your repertoire with it.
What We Liked
This pie plate has a deeply-fluted edge that makes it quite attractive, but the design counts for much more than the aesthetics. With it, you can produce crusts that are beautifully scalloped. It is made of high-fired ceramic material that can withstand heat for longer cook times without ever being in danger of cracking. It is built to resist odors and stains as well. It’s dishwasher safe, and it has a four-cup capacity. What’s especially nice about it, though, is the way you can use it for so many different recipes. If you want to try your hand at something like a Shepherd’s Pie, you can do so. You can make quiches, crumbles, or something more ambitious. It also doubles as a sturdy serving plate. Buy Here.
Best Value
Pyrex Easy Grab Glass 9.5 Inch Pie Plate
Pair of Reliable Pie Dishes. This set of two pie dishes are made of high-quality, non-porous, tempered glass. They’re a popular gift item for newlyweds and housewarming parties.
What We Liked
In some cases, two pie dishes are better than one. This could be ideal for the avid baker. Made by Pyrex, a trusted name in the industry, these dishes measure a full 9.5 inches across. If you have a sizeable gathering, and you want to try a couple of different pies rather than one, this set allows you to do that with ease. The tempered glass can withstand both hot and cold temperatures, so they’ll do fine in a microwave, freezer, dishwasher, or preheated oven. They are also built to repel odors, and they won’t absorb stains either. Purchase Yours Online.
Most Durable
Le Creuset PG1855-2367 Heritage Stoneware Pie Pan
Tough, Lovingly-Crafted Dish. This pie dish was built to last with its impermeable finish that can withstand extremes of both cold and heat.
What We Liked
If there was a heavyweight division for pie dishes, this one would likely reign supreme. It is made of dense stoneware that blocks any sort of moisture absorption. That is what eventually leads to cracks and rippling in some other materials, but you will never see that with this dish. It boasts less than 1% porosity, so you can use it again and again. It won’t ever get damaged. It stands up to extremes of cold and heat, so it will do fine in the dishwasher, freezer, microwave, oven, or even a broiler. It also comes in a bold cherry-red that would look right at home on any rustic farmhouse table. Order Here.